Home » Course » Dessert

Holiday Sugar Cookie Cups

This post may contain affiliate links.

Bite-sized cookie cups always seem to be a hit wherever I take them and I love how customizable they are! For the holidays, I created 12 festive variations to help celebrate all season long!

Graphic of 12 sugar cookie cups flavors all pieced together.

Before we get into all of the fun flavors, let me explain how a cookie cup works. It’s simple, I promise.

  1. Base – Each cookie cup starts with cookie dough or brownie batter. It will turn into the “cup” that holds all the goodies! I highly recommend using a silicone mini muffin pan for these so the cookies don’t stick!!
  2. Roll-In – Some of the holiday cookie cups have an ingredient(s) that the ball of dough is “rolled-in” before being baked. Think of it like the cinnamon sugar mixture you’d roll a snickerdoodle in before baking.
  3. Filling(s) – Each cookie cup will be filled with some sort of filling/frosting, etc…otherwise, what’s the point of cookie “cup?!”
  4. Topping(s)/Garnish(es) – Especially with the holiday sugar cookie cups, the toppings and garnishes add so much festive energy!

For each of the flavors below, I’ll list the base, roll-ins, fillings, and toppings. The base recipes will be linked and are at the bottom of the post.

It’s TIIIIIIIIME! Let’s check out these holiday flavors….Give one a try or make them all for a super fun, cheerful cookie platter!

A chocolate peppermint sugar cookie cup.

Chocolate Peppermint Brownie Cups

BASE: Brownie Cups

FILLING: White Chocolate Peppermint Buttercream (about 2 teaspoons per brownie cup).

Melt one 4-ounce bar of white chocolate; set aside to cool for 5 minutes. Add 1/2 cup of salted butter to the bowl of a stand mixer and mix until smooth. Add 2 cups of powdered sugar and 1/4 – 1/2 teaspoon peppermint extract (depending how strong you want it). Stir then add the white chocolate and mix until smooth. Add 1-2 tablespoons of milk or heavy cream, if needed.

TOPPING/GARNISHES: Crushed peppermint candies or candy canes.

An eggnog sugar cookie cup with a snowflake designed piece of white chocolate on top.

Eggnog Cookie Cups

BASE: Sugar Cookie Cups

ROLL-IN: Combine 1/3 cup sugar with 1/2 teaspoon nutmeg. Roll the cookie dough balls in the mixture before baking.

FILLING: Eggnog Buttercream (use about 2 teaspoons in each of the cookie cups).

Add 1 cup of salted butter to the bowl of a stand mixer and beat until smooth. Add 4 cups of powdered sugar and 1/4 teaspoon nutmeg and stir. Add 4-5 tablespoons of eggnog or until the frosting is a good consistency for piping.

TOPPING/GARNISHES: Add a small dollop of whipped topping and/or a simple snowflake-shaped piece of white chocolate!

Milk being poured into a chocolate-lined chocolate chip cookie cup.

Santa’s Milk & Cookies Cups

BASE: Chocolate Chip Cookie Cup

FILLING: Melt 12 ounces of chocolate until smooth. Spoon the chocolate into the cookie cups and be sure to spread it up the walls of the cups all the way up to the rim. Add a rim of sprinkles if desired. Refrigerate until solidified then fill the center with milk!

NOTES: Don’t add the milk until you’re ready to serve so it doesn’t leak out!

A turtle cookie cup with a pecan pressed into the middle.

Turtle Cookie Cups

BASE: Sugar Cookie Cups or Brownie Cups

ROLL-IN: Finely chopped pecans (skip this step if using the brownie cups)

FILLING: Combine one 11-ounce bag of Caramel Bits and 1/3 cup of heavy cream and microwave until smooth. Spoon about 1-2 teaspoons of the caramel sauce into each of the cups. These will be very similar to my Twix Cookie Cups (if you want an option without nuts)!

TOPPING/GARNISHES: Add a sprinkle of flaky sea salt, a pecan half, and a drizzle of chocolate.

A "Santa Hat" brownie cup.

Santa’s Hat Cookie Cups

BASE: Sugar Cookie Cups or Brownie Cups

FILLING: Whipped topping and a whole strawberry

TOPPING/GARNISHES: Pipe about 1 tablespoon of whipped topping into each of the 40 brownie cups. Remove the stems from the strawberries and press one into each brownie bite. Add a small dollop of whipped cream on top to resemble the pom-pom on top of Santa’s hat!

NOTES: This one works best if assembled within an hour or two so the whipped topping doesn’t have time to weep.

Hot chocolate brownie cup.

Hot Chocolate Sugar Cookie Cups

BASE: Brownie Cups

FILLING: Marshmallow Frosting

Add 1/2 cup of salted butter to the bowl of a stand mixer and mix until smooth. Add 1 cup of powdered sugar, one 7-ounce tub of marshmallow creme, and 1 teaspoon of vanilla; stir until smooth. Add about 2 teaspoons of the frosting in each of the cups.

TOPPING/GARNISHES: A chocolate drizzle and dehydrated marshmallows (Mallow Bits).

Gingerbread sugar cookie cup with a teeny tiny gingerbread on top.

Gingerbread Cookie Cups

BASE: Sugar Cookie Cups

ROLL-IN: Combine 1/3 cup sugar with 1/4 teaspoon ginger and 1/2 teaspoon cinnamon. Roll the cookie dough balls in the mixture before baking.

FILLING: Gingerbread Buttercream

In the bowl of a stand mixer, combine 3/4 cup of salted butter and 1 tablespoon molasses. Add 3 cups powdered sugar, 1 1/2 teaspoons ground ginger, 1 teaspoon cinnamon, and 1/4 teaspoon of cloves and stir. Add 2-3 tablespoons of milk or heavy cream, or until the frosting is the desired consistency. This will make enough to have at least 2 teaspoons of frosting in each of the 48 cookie cups.

TOPPING/GARNISHES: Small gingerbread cookies or gingerbread shaped sprinkles work great!

A cranberry orange sugar cookie cup with a sugared cranberry and orange peel on top for garnish.

Cranberry Orange Sugar Cookie Cups

BASE: Sugar Cookie Cups

ROLL-IN: Combine 1/3 cup sugar with 1 teaspoon orange zest and rub together with your fingers until fragrant and until the zest is evenly distributed. Roll the cookie dough balls in the mixture before baking.

FILLING: Cranberry Orange Frosting

In a small saucepan, combine 1 cup of cranberries and 2 tablespoons orange juice. Place over medium heat and let the cranberries cook for several minutes or until thick and jammy. Use an immersion blender to break up the skins a bit then let the mixture cool completely. Add 4 ounces of softened cream cheese and 6 tablespoons of softened butter to a bowl and stir until smooth. Add 2 1/2 cups of powdered sugar and 1/4 cup of the cranberry mixture. Stir until smooth, adding remaining cranberry mixture the extra moisture is needed. Makes enough for at least 2 teaspoons of frosting in each of the 48 cookie cups.

TOPPING/GARNISHES: Top with sugared cranberries and/or curled orange peel!

Snow globe sugar cookie cups.

Snow Globe Sugar Cookie Cups

BASE: Sugar Cookie Cups or Brownie Cups

FILLING: Use whatever light-colored frosting you’d like! Vanilla buttercream is my go-to, just like I use in my standard Sugar Cookie Cups!

TOPPING/GARNISHES: Top the frosting with sparkling sugar or flaked coconut to create a bed of “snow.” Then add any festive sprinkles or candy “trees” in the snow. Add a dusting of powdered sugar for a snow-covered look! Top each cookie cup with a small ornament half to create the “globe” look! *Be sure those enjoying the cookie cups know that the “globe” toppers are not edible.*

A Christmas tree made of a pretzel stick and melting candy pressed into a sugar cookie cup.

Christmas Tree Sugar Cookie Cups

BASE: Sugar Cookie Cups or Brownie Cups

FILLING: Whatever flavor of frosting you’d like!

TOPPING/GARNISHES: To make the Christmas tree garnishes, break pretzel sticks in half and place them on a sheet of waxed paper. Microwave colored candy melts until smooth then pipe them into a tree shape over the pretzel stick. Add sprinkles right away, if desired. Let solidify then press them into the center of your cookie cups.

Pecan pie cookie cup with a dollop of whipped topping.

Pecan Pie Cookie Cups

BASE: Sugar Cookie Cups

FILLING: Add 1/2 cup salted butter, 3/4 cup brown sugar, 1/2 cup corn syrup, and 1/4 cup heavy cream in a saucepan. Place over medium heat, stirring frequently, until it reaches a boil. Boil for 3 minutes. Remove from the heat and stir in 2 cups of chopped pecans and 1 teaspoon vanilla. Let cool completely before filling the cookie cups. This makes enough for at least 2 teaspoons of filling per sugar cookie cup.

TOPPING/GARNISHES: Add a dollop of whipped topping right before serving!

Funfetti sprinkle cookies on a tray.

Holiday Funfetti Sugar Cookie Cups

BASE: Sugar Cookie Cups

ROLL-IN: Sprinkles, if desired.

FILLING: Your choice! Vanilla buttercream (like in my original sugar cookie cups recipe) is a classic option!

TOPPING/GARNISHES: Sprinkles!!!

Base Flavors and How to Make Them

Brownie Cups

Preheat the oven to 350F. Prepare a box of fudge brownie mix according to the package instructions and scoop about 1 tablespoon of batter into silicone mini muffin pans. It’ll make about 40.

Bake them for 10-13 minutes, one pan at a time. The tops of the brownies will be shiny and the centers will be soft but no longer gooey. Soon after they’re removed from the oven, press the lid from an extract bottle into the center to create a cup. Let them cool completely before removing them from the pan(s).

Sugar Cookie Cups

You can either use a package of sugar cookie dough OR make your own by using my homemade sugar cookie cups recipe! If using a 24-count package of sugar cookie dough (I recommend the Pillsbury Eat or Bake Cookie Dough), you’ll start by cutting each of the 1 ounce dough balls into two.

Roll each 1/2 ounce dough piece into a ball (you’ll end up with 48) and place into a silicone mini muffin pan. Bake one pan at a time at 350F for 10-13 minutes. (Note: If using a nonstick metal pan, start the timer at 8 minutes as it won’t take as long as silicone pans). The very edges of the cookie cups will be a light golden brown and the centers will be soft.

Bake them for 10-13 minutes, one pan at a time. The tops of the brownies will be shiny and the centers will be soft but no longer gooey. Soon after they’re removed from the oven, press the lid from an extract bottle into the center to create a cup. Let them cool completely before removing them from the pan(s).

Chocolate Chip Cookie Cups

You can use a 24-count package of chocolate chip cookie dough (such as Pillsbury) or you can use a homemade chocolate chip cookie dough. Use about 1 ounce of dough (2 tablespoons) in each well of the mini muffin pan. These work great for the Santa’s Milk & Cookies Cups as they’re deeper and can be filled with milk. If you’d like to make them smaller, simply cut the dough balls in half.

If making the full (1 ounce) cups, you’ll bake them for 12-15 minutes. If cutting them in half, bake for 8-12 minutes. You want them to be golden brown when they come out of the oven. Be sure to press the lid of an extract bottle into the center of each while they’re still hot.

Let cookie cups cool completely before removing from the pan(s) and then fill!

So…which will you try first?! Leave a comment in the reviews below – can’t wait to hear what you make!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *